STATE OF M.P Vs BHARAT

16 January 2009
Supreme Court
Download

STATE OF M.P Vs BHARAT

Bench: TARUN CHATTERJEE,H.L. DATTU, , ,
Case number: Crl.A. No.-000080-000080 / 2009
Diary number: 6719 / 2007
Advocates: Vs K. SARADA DEVI

Page 1
Page 2
1

� � � � � � � � � � �     � �

�� � �  � ��� � �� �� � �� �� � � �� �� � � �� �� �� � ��   � ��� �     �� � � ��� � � � �� � � � �

� � � � � � �   � � � �� �   � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �  ! " �  #� �   � � � � � $� %� �  � � � &� � �  #� � � �’ %

�" (" ) �  # � �(* +, ( � ��( * )� + � �� � � - �. .) $$( �"

/ � � � � �

+ (� ( " � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � - �) �.  �* )� "

� � � � � � � � � �

0�  ) (1 ) � ��( � ") * � �

2. � � $� 2�" )* � � "� 3) � 4( � � ��� ! )* � 5, � "+� � � � ! � " �  � � � "+�  #� �(, 6

�� �� 6� 4+�3+��! � � �(� � !� *) � � 7�

8 �� �! ) � �  " �3 ) � � � � "� 3) � " � �" (" ) � (� � " � 4+, � 3�, . "� 3�  �* ) � .( �� ) * � 5, � "+) �   �� +� � ! � " � � + ! $* � � " � 5) �) " � ( � � *) � 5, � � )2� " " � �� � "+) � 2( "" ) � � " � "+)  � �+ � � !� " � " � 5) � * ) 3� * ) * � �� � ( 33 � * ( �3 ) 4� "+ � $(4� 9

:� �# ") � � � " � 3)6� ��� � ; � � �(� ( *( � � )1� � ) �") � ) * � (.. ) (� (� 3) � ( � *

+( � � (.. ) ( � )* � 5)# � ) � ! � � ($ �  � � � <) � +(1) � +)(� * � " +) � $) ( � �) *

3 !� � )$ � # � � "+) � .(� " �) � � ( � * � ( $� � ) =(2� � ) * � "+) � � 2. !� � ) *

� *) � �  # � " +) �  � �+ � �  !� " � (�* � ( $� � "+) � $� 2�" )* � �  " � 3)

�� �! ) * � 5, � "+�� � � !� " � � � <) � (�) �  # � " +) � 1� ) 4 � "+( " � "+)

�2 .! � �) * �  � * )� �  #� "+) �   � �+ � � !� " � 2(, � 5) � � ) " � ( �� *) � (� *

1

2

"+) � 2(" " ) � � 2( , � 5) � �) 2� "" )* � 5(3>� " � "+) �  �� +� �  ! �" � "   

*) 3� * ) � � � �3 � � �� $� � � (�) � �  � � 0&&:? �� �@�  � � 2) �� "� � ��

(33 � *( �3 ) � 4� " + � $(4 � (# �) � + � 4� "+� � � ( � .)� �  * �  # � "4  

2 �" +� � #�  2 � "+) � * ( " ) �  # � . �  *! 3"�  � �  # � ( � 3 ., �  #� "+� �

� *) � � " � "+) �   ��+ � �  !� " � � �

A� �3 3 � *� �� $,6 � "+) � �2 . !� � ) * �  � * )� �  # � "+) �  �� +� �  ! �" � ��

�) " � (�� * ) � � � �+ ) � (.. ) ($ � � � � "+! � � ($$ 4) * � 4�" +� � �  � * )� � ( �

" � 3 �" � � � � �� � � � �� � � �

- - - - - - - - - - � � B� � � � � � �   � � � � � � � � C

� � <� � �    � D � � � � � � � � � � � - - - - - - - - - � � � � � � � � � E� 0@6� � � � � � � � � � � B  �   � � � � � � � C

2