SIPRA BHATTACHARYYA Vs APARES BHATTACHARYYA
Bench: TARUN CHATTERJEE,H.L. DATTU, , ,
Case number: C.A. No.-000307-000307 / 2009
Diary number: 34632 / 2008
Advocates: Vs
RANJAN MUKHERJEE
� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� � � � ��� � �� �� � �� �� � � �� �� � � �� � � � � � ��� � �� � � ��� � �� �� �� � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � " #$� " %� � � � � &� � " � � � ’ ( ) � � " %� � � � *&
�� +� , � -, $$, . - , �/ /, � � �� � � � �0 �+ +122, $
� � � � � �
�� � � �+, � 1� � -, $$, . - , �/ /, � 0 �1 � +" 3 1 $ �
� � � � � � � � �
’� 1 ,4 1� !�, $13� �
2. � �- 1� ,++122, $5� 61� ! � $- 1� 7� %1� " %� $-1 � �1 � +" 31 $ 5� - , �
%�213� , � � +1. � , 2� 1, 41� �1 $�$ �" � � 118� ! � 21,41� $" � , ++1, 2
%�"9 � $-1 � %� , 2 � "� 31� � 3,$13 � ’* $-� " %� � 1+$1961� 5 � � � � *
+, �� 13� 6/ � $- 1� �! - � �"# � $� "%� � ,2. #$$, � � � � � � � � � " � � ��: �
"%� � ��� � � � / � $-1 � �9 +#! 1 3� "�3 1�5 � $-1 � ,%" �1 �, �3 � �� 4�2
�1 4� � �" � �,� 1� 7-� . - � 7, � � %�213� # 31� � ��$ � .2 1� ��� � " %� $-1
�" � $�$ #$� " � ,$ � $-1 � � � $, . 1� "%� $- 1� -#� 6, 3; � 1� +" 31 $
,! ,� �$ � , � "�3 1� � 3, $13� � � $- � "%� �,/ 5� � � � � � +,� � 13� 6/ � $-1
21,� 13� �3 3� $� " , 2� ��� $� �. $� , 3 � �1 � �� " � � � #3!1 5� � 2�+ " � 1
7, � � 3�� +" �1 3� "%� 6/ � 3�� 1. $� ! � $- 1� $��, 2� ."# � $� $" � 3��+ " � 1
"%� $-1� � #�$ � %"� � 3�4 " �. 1� +�1%1�, 62/ � 7� $- � � , � /1, � � %�"9
$-1 � 3, $1 � " %� � #++2/ � "%� , � ."+ / � " %� $- , $ � " � 31� � � 1 � �$
91 $ � " 13� -1 �1 � � $- , $� $- 1� " � 31� � "%� 9, � $1 , . 1� +, � �1 3
1
6/ � $-1� � 33� $� " , 2� � ��$ � � . $� �# 3!1 5� �2� +" �1 � 6/ � $- 1� "�3 1�
3, $13� � � $- � " %� � ,/ 5� � � � �5 � $-1� 7�%1; , ++122, $� 7,� � ! �, $13
9, � $1 , . 1�+1 31 $1� 2�$ 1� ,$ � ��� ( � � �; � � +1� � 9" $ - � � �
�� �" � � +�" +1� � 3�� +"� , 2 � "%� $-�� � ,+ +1,2 5� 7-� . - � � 12, $1� � $"
1 -, .1 91 $ � "%� 9, � $1 , . 1 � +, /, 621� 6/ � $-1 � -# � 6, 3 � $"
$-1� 7� %1; ,+ +122, $5� $-1� %,.$� � 7- � . - � , � 1� 1 .1 � �, �/ � $" � 61
�$ ,$ 13�,� 1� ,� � %"22" 7� �<�
�- 1� +,� $� 1� � 71� 1� 9, � �� 13� " � � � $- � " %� �1+$1961� 5
’� �* � � � �- 1� - #� 6, 3; �1 � +" 3 1 $� -, � � %�213� , � +1$�$ �"
%"� � 3�4 " � .1 � " � $-1� !�" # 3� � 91 $� " 13� � � $-1� � , � 3
+1$� $�" � � � � . . "� 3� ! � $" � $- 1 � 7� %1;, ++122, $5 � $-1
-# �6 , 3 ;� 1�+ " 31 $ � �� � , � �.� 1 $�� $ � , 3 � - ,� � 611
1, � � ! � , � - , 3�" 91� � ,2 ,� / � " %� 9"� 1� $-, � � � � (� 5�� �; �
+1� � 9" $- � � � =- 1� 1,� 5 � $- 1 � ,+ +122, $5 � ,2$ - "# ! -
-� !- 2/ � 13#., $135 � .2 , �9 13 � $- , $ � �- 15 � 61� ! � $-1
-" #� 17� %1� 7� $- � ,6 �" 2#$12/ � " � �"# � . 1 � "%� � . " 915
-, 4� ! � 611 � 21%$� 1 $� � 12/ � " � - 1� � " 7 � $" � %1 3
-1 �� 12%5� -,3 � $" � %� 21� , � , ++2� . ,$ �" � # 31� � �1 .$ � "
�( � " %� $- 1 � � 3# � �,� � �, !1 � �. $ � �� � � -"� $5 � > $-1
�. $? &��1 18� ! � ,2 �9 " / � +1 31 $1�2� $1� � �
4. / � , � "�3 1� � 3, $13 � � � $- � "%� �,/ 5 � � � � �5 � $-1 � , ++2� ., $�"
# 31� � � 1. $� " � �( � " %� $-1� � .$ � 7,� � +, �$ 2/ � ,22 " 713� , 3� $-1
,+ +122, $ � 7, � � ,7, � 313 � 6/ � $- 1 � $� � ,2 � �" #� $ � , � � #9 � " %
�� �( � �� ;� � +1� � 9" $- � � � �# 6�1 @#1 $ 2/ 5 � � � 1� � ,%$1� � %� 41
2
/1 ,� � 5� $-1� , ++122, $� %"# 3� $- , $� $- 1� ,9" # $ � ,7 , � 313� 7, �
" $� �#%%� . �1 $� %"� � - 1� � �# � $1 , . 15� , 3� ,.. " � 3� !2 / � 9,3 1
, � , ++2� . , $� " � � � $-1� 9" $- � "%� �+� � 25� � ��* � � � $- 1� � " #� $
"%� $-1 � 21,� 13 � � 33� $� " , 2 � ��� $�� .$ � �# 3! 15 � �2 � +"� 1
�1 18� ! � 1 -, . 191 $ � "%� $-1� 9, � $ 1 , . 1 � +1 31 $ 1 � 2�$1 5
7- �. - � 7,� � ,2 �1 , 3/ � , 7,� 313� � � $-1� / 1,� � � ��� � � �
:� �$ � �� � "$� � � 3� � +#$1� $- , $� $-1 � " � � ! � , 2� "�3 1� � !� , $� !
�� �( � �� ;� � +1� � 9" $- � , � � 9, � $1 , .1 � 7, � � .-, 221 ! 13� 6/
$-1 � 7�%1; ,+ +122, $ � � � $- 1 � �! - � � " #�$ � "%� � , 2. #$$, � �
�1 4� � �" 5 � 7- �. - � .,9 1� $" � 61� �1 ! �� $1� 13� , � � ��� � � �"� � �� :�
"%� � ��� � � �
)� / � $-1 � �9 +#! 1 3� "�3 1�5 � $-1 � 21, � 13� �# 3! 1� " %� $- 1� �!-
�" #� $ � 3�� +"� 13 � "%� $-1 � ,%" �1 �, �3 � �� 4�2 � � 14� � � " � �, �1 5
� $1� � ,2� , 5�6/ � 3� �1 . $� ! � ,� � %"22" 7� � <�
> �%$1� � . " �� 31� � ! � $-1 � �# 69� � � � " � � 9,31 6/ � $-1 � 21, � 13 � , 34" ., $1� � ,+ +1, �� ! � " 61-, 2%� "%� $-1� +,� $� 1� � , 3� #+" � +1�#�� ! $-1 � � � $, $ � ,+ +2� . , $�" � , 3 � $-1 � " � 31� �9 +#! 1 35� � � ,9 � "%� $-1 � " +� � " � $- ,$ � %" � $-1 � � $ 1� 1�$ � " %� A#�$�. 1 � $-1 � 21,� 13 ." #� $� 612" 7� 9, / � 61� 3�� 1. $13� $" � -1, � � "#$ , 3 � 3�� +" �1 � "%� $- 1 � ��� . 122, 1 " #� � �, �1 �" � � �� � "% � �� �’ � ,� �� � ! � "#$ � "% �, $� � 9" � , 2 � �# � $ � � " � � (� � " %� � � �’ � ,� 1B+13�$ �" #�2 / � , � � +" �� � 6215 � +� 1%1� , 62/ 7� $- � � , � +1� � " 3� " %� $1 � 9" $ -� 5� 6#$� " $ 2, $1� � $-, � $71241� 9" $ -� � %�"9 � $-1� 3,$1 "%� ." 99# � ., $� " � "%� $- � � � "� 31� � 7�$ -" #$ !� , $� ! � # 1. 1�� ,� / � ,3A" #� 91 $ � � $" � $-1 +, �$ � 1� �
�- 1 � $� 91� %� , 91 � � 3� ., $13 � ,6 "41 �- ,2 2 � 61 � +1�19+$" � / � � � , $#�1 � , 3 � �$ �- ,2 2� " $� 61� "+1 � $" � $- 1� 21,� 13� ." #� $
3
612"7� $" � 1B$1 $� $-1 � � , 91� 141 � " � ." � 1 $ "%� $-1 �+, � $� 1� � � �
� � 4� 17� " %� $- 1� ,6 "41� 3� � 1. $�" � �$ �- ,2 2� "$ � 61� " +1 � $" � $-1 � "++"� �$ 1� +,� $/ $" � +� 1� � � %"� � , / � 1 - , .1 91 $ � "%� $-1 1B�� $� ! � ,9" # $� "%� ,2� 9" / � +1 3 1 $1� 2�$ 1 61%"� 1�$- 1� 21, � 1 3� �"# � $� 612"7�
�- 1� , ++2� ., $� " � �$, 3� � 3� �+ "� 13� "% � � $1�9 � � "% � $- 1 � 3�� 1.$ �" � � !� 41 -1 �1 � , 6"41� ? �
�� �$ � �� � ,!, � � $ � $-� � � "�3 1� � "%� $-1 � � !- � �" #�$ � $- ,$ � $-1
7� %1; ,+ +122, $ � - , � � ."9 1 � #+ � 61%"� 1 � #� � 6/ � 7, / � "%� ,
�+ 1. � ,2 � 1 ,4 1 � �1$ � $� " 5 � 7-� .- � " � !� , $ � "%� 21,4 15 � 7,�
-1 ,� 3 � � � +� 1�1 . 1 � " %� $- 1 � 21, � 1 3 � . "# � 12 � %" � � $- 1
+, �$ � 1� � � � � � "# � � 4� 175� $-1� � ! - � �" #� $� 7,� � " $� A#�$�%�1 3
� � +, �� � ! � $-1 � � 9+#! 13 � "�3 1� � � � $-1 � 9, 1� � �$ � - , �
3" 1 � � � �$ � �� � "$ � 3� � +#$13� $-, $� $- 1� , ++2�. , $� " � # 31�
�1 .$ � " � �( � "%� $-1 � � .$ � 7, � � +,� $2/ � ,2 2" 713� 6/ � $-1 � $��, 2
�" #� $� � � $- 1� /1 ,� � � ��� � � �1� � , $� 21, � $� %�41� / 1,� � � 6,.8 �
�- 1� - , � � , 2�1 , 3/ � %�213� , � ,+ +2�. , $� " � 61%"� 1� $- 1� $��, 2
�" #� $� %"� � 1 -, . 191 $� " %� - 1� � 9, � $ 1 , . 1� %�"9� � �� (� � � ; �
+1� � 9" $- � � �
*� � � $-1� , ++2� . , $� " � %"� � 1 - , . 191 $ 5� $- 1� 7� %1� - , � � ,2� "
.2 ,� 913� $- ,$ � � � . 1 � $-1 � - #�6 , 3 � - , � � 611 � 1, � � ! � 9"�1
$- , � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� * �5 � � � ;� � +1� � 9" $- � " 75� $-1
9, � $1 , . 1 � , 9"# $ � �-" #23 � , 2� " � 61� � . �1 ,� 13� � � � %$1�
1B,9 � � ! � $-1� � 9+#! 1 3� " �31 � � "%� $-1� �! - � � "#�$ 5� 71� -,4 1
" � "$-1 � � ,2$1� ,$ �4 1 � 6#$ � $" � �, / � $- , $ � 4� �$ #,2 2/ 5 � $-1
4
,+ +2� ., $� " � %�213� 6/ � $-1 � 7� %1;, ++122, $� %"� � 1 - , . 191 $
"% � $-1 � 9, � $ 1 , . 15 � 7- � . - � �� � +1 3� ! 5 � - ,� � 611
�1 A1. $13� � � � #� $-1� 9"� 15� �$ � �� � ." 99" � 1B+1� � 1 .1 � $- , $� �
�+ �$ 1� " %� 3� � 1. $� " � � !� 41 � 6/ � $- 1� �!- � � "#� $5� %" � � $-1
�1 ,� " � � 61�$ � 8 "7 5 � 3� � 1.$ � " � � 9,31 � 6/ � �$ � . , " $ � 61
., �� � 13 � " #$� � � � � , / � 4�1 7 � "%� $-1 � 9, $$1� 5 � 7-1 � $- 1
,+ +2� ., $� " � %"� � 1 - , . 191 $� "%� $- 1� 9, � $1 , . 1� "%� $-1
,9 "# $� $" � $-1� 7�%1; , ++122, $� 7, � � +1 3 � ! � � � $- 1� � "#� $5
�$ � 7,� � �$ � � 3#$/ � $" � !" � � $" � $- , $� @#1�$ � " � , 3 � 3� �+ " �1 � " %
$-1 � � ,� 3 � ,++2� . ,$ �" � 61%"� 1 � $-1 � � #�$ � %"� � 3� 4"� . 1 � ��
3� �+ " �1 3� "%� 6/ � � $� � � � ��� � �, A, � � #8-1� A115� ,+ +1,� � ! � "
61-, 2%� "%� $- 1� - #� 6, 3 ; � 1�+ " 31 $5� �#6 9� $� � $- ,$ � �%� $-1
�9 +#! 1 3� " � 31� � " %� $-1� � !- � �" #� $� , $� $-� � � �$, ! 1� � � � �1 $
,� �3 15 � $- 1� 3�� +"� , 2 � "%� $-1 � � , $� � 9" � , 2 � �#� $ � � -, 22� 61
# 1 . 1� �, � �2 / � 312,/ 13� � � � " �� 31� � ! � $-� � � , � +1. $� " %� $- 1
9, $$1�5 � 71 � $-1� 1%" � 1 � 3� � +"� 1 � "%� $- �� � ,+ +1, 2 � � � $-1
%"22" 7� ! � 9, 1�< �
�’ &�- 1 � 7�%1; ,+ +122, $ � �-, 22 � 61 � 1 $� $213 � $"
� � � � �� � ; � � +1� � 9" $- � � �$ 1,3 � "%� ��� ( �� � ; � � +1�
9" $- � %�" 9� $-1 � 3, $1� "%� %�2� ! � $- 1� ,++2� . ,$ � "
# 31� � � 1. $� " �� ( � "%� $- 1�� .$ � ��
�� &�- 1� ,�� 1, � � � "%� 9, � $1 , . 1 � � � 1� � 3� %%1�1 . 1 � "%
� � � � �� � ; � � +1� � 9" $- � � � 1� � %�"9 � �� �( � �� ; � � $"
� � � � �� � ; � � 7"#23 � 61 � +,� 3; 31+" � �$ 13 � 6/ � $-1
5
- #� 6, 3; � 1� +" 31 $� 7�$ - � � $-� 11� 9" $- � � %� " 9� $- � �
3, $1� $" � $-1 � 7� %1; ,+ +122, $ � � � ��2 2� $-1 � 31. � �� "
" %� $-1 � � #�$ 5 � $-1 � - #�6 , 3 � � - , 22 � ! " � "
+, / � ! ; 31+"� � $� ! � C� �� �� � �� ;� � +1� � 9" $- � $" � $-1
7� %1;, ++122, $� �# 6A1.$ � $" � , / � %#�$ - 1� � "� 31� � $-, $
9, / � 61� +, �� 13 � � � $- 1 � 141 $5� $-1 � �# � $ � � � � " $
31. � 313� 6/ � $-1 � � " #� $� 7�$ - � � $-1 � $� 91� �+ 1.� %�13
- 1� 1� � 612"7� "� � � . �1 , �1 � "%� $-1� � , �3 � 9, � $1 , . 1
" %� �� � � �� � ;� � +1� � 9" $ - � �� � 1. 1� � � $, $13� %"� � , /
� 1, � " � 7- ,$ � "141� � �� � � � �
(3) � �- 1� $�� ,2 � �" #� $� �� � 3�� 1. $13� $" � 3�� +"� 1� " %� $-1
� #� $� +"�� $�4 12/ � 7� $-� � , � / 1, � � %�"9 � $- 1� 3,$1� " %
� #++2/ � "%� , � . " +/ � "%� $- � � � " � 31� � $" � � $ � 7� $- " #$
! � , $� ! � , / � # 1.1 � �, �/ � , 3A" #� 91 $ � � $" � 1�$ - 1�
" %� $-1� +, �$ � 1� � � � � �� �
�( &�- 1 � ,++2� ., $� " � %"� � 1 -, . 191 $ � "% � $-1
9, � $1 , .1 � %�213� 6/ � $- 1� 7� %1; ,+ +122, $ � 7- �. - � � �
" 7 � +1 3� ! � 61%"� 1 � $-1 � $� �, 2 � . "# �$ � %" �
, 3A#3� . , $�" � �� 5� $- 1� 1%"�1 5� 3� �+ "� 13� "%� �
(5) � - 1� " � 31� � 3, $13� � � $-� "%� �,/ 5� � �� � � +, � �1 3� 6/ � $-1
� 33� $� " , 2 � � � � $� � . $ � �# 3! 15 � �2 � +"� 1 � 7- �. - � 7,�
# 31� � .-, 221 ! 1 � 61%" �1 � $-1 � � !- � � " #� $ � �
� 14� �� " � 6/ � 7- � .- � $-1� 9, � $1 , . 1� " %� � � �( � �� ;�
6
+1� � 9" $- � 7, � � ! �, $ 13� $" � $-1� 7�%1; ,+ +122, $� � �
, 2� " � 9" 3� %�13�$ " � $- 1� 1B$1 $� � 3� ., $13� ,6 "41� �
�� =� $- � $-1 � , %" �1 �, � 3 � 3�� 1. $� " � 5 � $- 1 � ,+ +1, 2 � ��
3� �+ " �1 3� "%�� � � -1 �1 � 7� 22� 61� " � " �3 1� � , � � $" � ." � $�� � �
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � �
D� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � E
� � =� � � � F � � � � � � � � � � � 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � � � � � � � � � G� ’ � 5� � � � � � � � � � � � D � � � � � � � � � E
7