06 February 2009
Supreme Court
Download

MADAN LAL Vs HARDEEP KAUR

Bench: TARUN CHATTERJEE,H.L. DATTU, , ,
Case number: C.A. No.-000763-000763 / 2009
Diary number: 33900 / 2007
Advocates: Vs P. N. PURI


1

� � � � � � �� � � �     �

� � � � � � �   � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �   � � � � �     � � � � � � � �   � � � � � � �

� � � �   � � � � � �   � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �  � ! " � � #$� � %�     � &� ’ � � � � � � � � � � � %� � � � � ’

�( )( ! �  (* � + � � ,,- * * ( !$

� � �   �   

�( �) - -, � . (#� � + �-  ,� !) - !$

� � � � � � � � �

/�  - (0 - � "�( ! $- ) �

2. �1 � � ( , , - (* � � � ) � � - 2$- ) � ("( � !  $� ( � %�!( * � � � ) - �

)( $- ) � /� $1� � %� �2$ � 3- �4 � �� � � � , (  - ) � 35 � (

*- (� ! -) � � #)" - � �%� $1- � ��" 1� ��# � $� �%� �# !6 ( 3� ( ! )

�( �5 ( !( � ($ � �1( ! )� "( �1 � � ! � �� 0� * � � -0 � � � ! � �(  -

�� � � ��7 � � �%��� � �� � �

�� �1 - � � -  ,� !) - !$ � �( �) -- , � . (#� � 1( ) � %� *- ) � ( !

-0 �2 $�� ! � , - $�$ �� ! � #!)- � �  -2 $� � ! � /� � �%� $1-

�(  $ � �# !6 ( 3� �� 3(! � � -!$ � � - $ � � 2$� �! � �2 $4� /� �8 �

�1 - � (,, - * * (! $ � -!$ - � - ) � (, , -( � ( ! 2- � 3-%�� - � $1-

�- !$ � � � ! $�� * *- �4 � � 1(! ) � " (� 14 � (!) � %�* - ) � 1�  

1

2

9� �$ $-! �  $ ( $-: - !$ � )- ! 5�! " � $1- � :( $- �� ( *

(* *- " ($ �� !  �:( ) - ��! � $1- � -0� 2$� �! � , -$� $� � !� � �

8� �1 - � $�� ( * � �� #� $ � 1() � %�(: - ) � �  #-  4 � �! - � �%

91�2 1 � 9(  � 91-$1-� � $1- �  # � $ � , � -: �  -  � 9(  

�- ;# � �- ) � 3�! ( %� )- � %�� � $1- � ,#� , � - � �%� ,- �  � ! ( *

!- 2-   � $5� �%� $1- � � -  , � !) -! $� � �  # 3 - ;# - ! $ � $�

$1- � %� * �! " � � %� $1- � 9� � $$- ! �  $( $- : - ! $4 � $1-

(, ,- * *( !$ � ( *  � � %�*- ) � ( : - !) - ) � 9�� $$- !

$ ($ - :- !$ <2� #! $-� � 2*( � :4 � ) - ! 5�! " � $1-

�- *( $�� ! 1�, � �%� *(! ) *� �) � ( ! ) � $-! ( ! $� (  � 9-* *

( � 3�!( � %�)- � � -;# � � - :- !$ � �%� $1- ��-  ,� ! ) - !$ �

5.  5 � (! � ��) - � � ) ( $- ) � / 8$1� �%� �#! - 4� � � � =4� $1- � � - ! $

�� !$ � �* *- � 4 � �1 ( !) �" ( �1 � 1( ) � ( * *� 9-) � $1-

-0 �2 $�� ! � ,-$ � $� �! � ( !) � �� ) -� - ) � -0 �2 $�� ! � �%� $1-

(, ,- * *( !$ � � � �" " �� -0 -) � 35� $1- � (%�� -  (� ) � ��) - �

�%� $1- � �- ! $� � � !$ � �* *- � 4 � $1- � ( ,,- * * ( !$ � %�*- )

(! � (, , - (* � 3- %� �- � $1- � � �  $� � 2$ � �# )" - 4 � �! � �!

�- �� � $� �5 4 � �1( ! )� " ( � 1� � � �#� � ! " � $1- � ,- !) - !2 5

�% � $1- � (, , -( *4 � $1- � (,, - * * (! $ � %�* -) � (!

(, ,* � 2($� � ! � %�� � (22- ,$ ( ! 2- � �% � () )� $�� !( *

-0 �) - !2 - � #!) - � � �� )- � � 8/ � � #* - � � � � �%� $1- � ��) -

�%� �� 0� * � � � � 2- )# � - � >�! �  1�� $ � ?$ 1- � �� )- @A�

�1 - � � � $� �2 $ � � #)" - 4 � � ! � � ! � �-� � �$ � � 54

2

3

�1 (! ) �" (� 1 �  #3  -; #- !$ *54 � 35 � ( ! � ��) - � � ) ( $- )

/8 $1� �%�  -, $- : 3- �4 � �� �� 4� )� : �  - ) � $1- � (, ,- (*

�%� $1- �(, , -* * ( ! $� � �

�� �1 - � ( , , -* *( ! $4 � $1-� -( %$- � 4 � :� 0-) � $1- � 2� 0� *

�- 0�  �� ! � 2(  - � 3- � !" � � � 0� * � � - 0� � � ! � �(  - � �� �

�� 7� � �%� � ��� � 3-%��- � $1- � � � " 1� ��# � $� 91�2 14� 35

$1- � � : , #" !- ) � � �)- � 4 � 9(  � ( *  � � �-6 - 2$- ) �

�- -* � !" � (" " � �- 0-) 4� $1- � (, ,- ** (! $� 1( � 2� :- � #,

35� 9(5 � �%� ( �  , - 2� ( * �  - (0 - � �-$ � $� � ! � $� � $1�  

�� #� $4� 91�2 1� � ! � " � ( !$ � �%� *- (0 - 4� 9(  � 1-( �) � � !

$1- � ,�-  - !2 - � �%� $1- � *- (� !- ) � 2� #!  - * � %�� � $1-

,( �$ � - � � �

�� �( 0� ! " � 1- ( �) � $1- � *- ( �! - ) � 2� #!  - * � %�� � $1-

,( �$ � - � (! ) � -B( :� !- ) � $1- � �: ,# "! - ) � ��) - � � (  

9- ** � ( � $1- � � $1- � � :( $- �� (*  � �! � �-2 � �) 4� �! � � #�

0� -94� $1- � �� )- � � , (   - ) � 35� $1- � �� "1 � �� #� $� � !

�- 0�  �� ! � 2( - � � � * � (3 * - � $� � 3- �  - $� (  � )- � �! � (

� :, * - � "� �# ! ) � � � � � ,* ( � ! � � - ( )� ! " � �% � $1-

�: ,# " !- ) � � � ) -� � 9� #* ) �  1� 9� $1( $� $1- � �- 0�  �� !

2(  - � 9(  � �-6 - 2$- ) � 35� $1- � �� "1 � �� #� $� � !* 5� � !

$1- � "�� #! ) � $1($� $1- � (, ,- ** ( ! $� 1( ) � %(�* - ) � $�

3� �! " � $� � $1- � ! �$� 2- � �%� $1- � �� #�$ � $1($ � $1-

(, ,* � 2($� � ! � #! ) -� � � �)- � � 8/ � �# * - � �� � �%� $1-

3

4

�� )- � 9(  � �-6 - 2$-) � 35� $1- � �, ,- * *( $- � �# $1� �� $54

(* $1� #"1 � $1- � ( ,,- * * ( !$ � 1( ) � $(C-! � ( � ,* -(

3-%�� - � $1- � � � " 1 � � � #�$ � $1( $ �  # 21 � (!

(, ,* � 2($� � ! � 1( 0� ! " � 3-- ! � %�* -) 4� 9( � ! � $� ($ � ( * *

$(C-! � � !$ � � 2� !  � ) - � ($ � � ! � 35 � $1- � ��  $� �2 $

�# )" - 4� 3- � !" � $1- � � , ,- * *( $- � � #$1� � � $5� � � �$ � �  

�! *5 � �! � $1�  � " ��# ! ) � $1($ � $1- � 2�0 � * � �- 0�  � � !

2(  - � 9(  � �-6 - 2$- ) � 35� $1- � �� "1 � �� #� $� � � � $� �   

$� #- � $1( $� $1- � ( ,, *� 2($� � ! � #!) - � � � � )- � � 8/ � � #* -

�� � � %� $1- � � � ) - 4� %�*- ) � 35� $1- � (,, - ** (! $4� 9(   

�- 6-2$- ) � 35� $1- � *-( � !- ) � �� $� � 2$� � #)" - 4� �! �� !

�- �� � $� �5 4 � � 1( !) � "( �1 4 � 3#$ � $1- � ��) - �

)�  : �   �! " � $1- � (, ,- ( * � ) � ) � !�$ �  1� 9� $1($ � $1- � -

9(  � ( ! 5 � � -%-� - !2 - � : ()- � $� � $1- � �- 6-2$� �! � � %

$1- � ( , , *� 2($ �� ! � �%� $1- � ( ,,- * * (! $� %�*- ) � #!) - �

�� )- � � 8/ � �#* - � � � � �%� $1- � ��) - � � � � � ,- �#  ( * � �%

$1- � � � ) -� � � %� $1- � � , ,- ** ( $- � �# $1� � � $5 � 9� #*)

(*  � �  1� 9� $1($ � $1- � (,, * � 2($ �� ! � #! ) -� � �� ) -� � 8/

�# *- � � � � � %� $1- � �� )- � 9(  � �-6 - 2$-) � �! � $1- �  ( : -

)( $- � 3#$� 35� ( �  - , (� ($ - � �� ) - �4 � 91�2 1� 9( � !� $

9� $1� ! � $1- � C!� 9*- )" - � � %� $1- � ( ,,- * * ( !$ � ( $� $1-

$� :- � $1- � !�$ � 2- � 9(  � �   #-) � 35� $1- � ��" 1� ��# � $

-! $- � $( �! � !" � $1- � �- 0� �� !( * � ( ,,* � 2( $� �! �

4

5

�0 -! � (   #:� ! " � $1($� $1- � %(2$ � �%�  #21� � - 6-2$�� !

9(  � !�$ � 3��# " 1$ � $� � $1- � ! �$� 2- � �%� $1- � �� " 1

�� #� $4� �$ � 2� #*) � ! � $� * - ( ) � $� � � -6- 2$� �! � � %� $1-

2� 0� * � �-0 �  � � ! � 2(  - � 9� $1� #$� ) -2� ) � ! " � $1- �  (: -

�! � : -�� $ � � � � 1-� - %��- 4� $1- � �� " 1� �� #�$ � 9( � ! � $

6# $ � %�-) � � ! � � -6- 2$� !" � $1- � 2� 0�* � �- 0�  � �!

2(  - � 9� $1�# $ � "� � ! " � �!$ � � $1- � :- � � $ � ( � $�

91-$1-� � $1- � � -  , � ! ) -! $ � 9( � -! $�$ *- ) � $� � (!

�� )- � � � %� - 0� 2$�� ! � � ! � $1- � " � � #!) � $1( $ �  1-

�- ;# � �- ) � $1- �  #�$ � , �-: �  -  � %�� � 1- � � �9 ! � # -

(! ) � �22 #, ( $� �! � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � �

7� �! � $1� � 0�-9 � �%� $1- � : ( $$-� 4� 9- �  - $� ( �) - � $1-

�� )- � � �%� $1- � � �"1 � � �#� $ � (!) �  -!) � $1- � 2(  -

3(2C� $� � �$ � %�� � %�- 1� )� , � (* � �! � ( 22� � ) (! 2-

9� $1� *( 9� � � �1- � �� "1 � �� #� $ � � � �-; #-  $- ) � $�

)�  , �  - � �%� $1- � :( $$- � � 9� $1� ! � $1� - - � :� !$ 1  

%��: � $1- � )($ - � � %� 2� : :# !� 2($�� ! � �%� ( � 2�, 5� � %

$1� � �� )- � � 9�$ 1�# $ � " �( !$ �! " � #!!- 2-   ( � 5

() 6� #�! :- ! $ � $� � -�$ 1-� � � %� $1-� ,( �$ � - � � �

�� �1 - � (,, - ( * � � � $1# � (** � 9-) � $� � $1- � -B$- ! $

�! )� 2($ -) � (3 �0 - � � � �1 -� - � 9� * * � 3- � !� � �� )- � � (   

$� � 2� $  � � � �

5

6

+ + + + + + + + + + + � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � ’

� � D� � �  � � E� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ++ + + + + + + + + + � � � �   � � � � F � � � 4 � � � � � � � � �   � � � � � � � ’

6