15 June 2009
Supreme Court
Download

M/S CLINIQUE LABORATORIES LLC Vs M/S GUFIC P.LIMITED

Case number: C.A. No.-004109-004109 / 2009
Diary number: 17197 / 2009
Advocates: Vs BHARGAVA V. DESAI


1

1

   IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA             CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

 CIVIL APPEAL NO.4109 OF 2009     (ARISING OUT OF SLP(C) NO.14283 of 2009)          

M/S CLINIQUE LABORATORIES LLC & ANR.                  .....APPELLANTS)

VERSUS

M/S GUFIC P.LIMITED & ANR.                            ....RESPONDENT(S)

             O  R  D  E  R

Leave granted. We have heard learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants as well as the  

respondents.

The High Court of Delhi by the impugned order dt.29.05.2009 stayed the operation of the  

judgment passed by the learned Single Judge granting injunction in favour of the appellants on  

16.12.2008 which was subsequently made absolute by the order dt.09.04.2009.   

It is an admitted fact that the appellant was on caveat.  The High Court did not grant any  

time to file counter. The appellants had the benefit of injunction in its favour eversince 16.12.2008.  

In our considered opinion, the High Court ought not to have suspended the operation of injunction  

order even at the stage of admission of F.A.O.    

In such circumstances, we find it difficult to sustain the impugned order.  The impugned  

order  is  accordingly  set  aside.   We,  however,  request  the  High Court  to  dispose  of  the appeal  

without being influenced by the interim order granted on 29.05.2009.  The appeal is accordingly  

allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.

Liberty is granted to the parties to request the High Court to  advance the hearing of the  

matter.     

2

2

                .............................J.                            ( B.SUDERSHAN REDDY)

                .............................J.                            ( AFTAB ALAM )

NEW DELHI; JUNE 15, 2009.