M/S BACHAN TRADERS Vs STATE OF BIHAR .

31 March 2009
Supreme Court
Download

M/S BACHAN TRADERS Vs STATE OF BIHAR .

Case number: C.A. No.-002117-002119 / 2009
Diary number: 2604 / 2008
Advocates: GAURAV AGRAWAL Vs GOPAL SINGH

Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
1

� � � � � � � � � � � � � �     � � � � �   �   � �   � � � � �� � � � � � � � �     � � � � � � � � �   � � � � � � �   �

� � � � � � �     � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �   � � � � � � � � � � � �  ! � � " #� � $� � �   � � � %� � � �� � &� �’ � &� �( � � $� � � � &%

�) �� � *+,- + ��� +./ � � � �

0 �1 1/2 2+ #

�/ �� " �

�# +#/ � �$ � *�- +� � 3� � � � �

0  / � 1�  . /  # �

4� #- �

� � � � � � �     � � � � � � � � � � ’ ’ � � � ’ ( �   � � � � � � � � � � � �  ! � � " #� � $� � �   5� � � � � � ( � ’ � � � ( � ( � � $� � � �&%

�) �� � *+,- + ��� +./ � � � �

0 �1 1/2 2+ #

�/ �� " �

�# +#/ � �$ � *�- +� � 3� � � � � 0  / � 1�  . /  # �

 �   � � � � �   �

�� �/ 2+6� ,� . � / . �

�� �/ +7/ � !�+  #/ . �

8� �- /� / � +11/+ 2� � - +7/ � 9//  � $�2 / . � +! +�  � # � + � � � . /�

1+�� / . � 96 � #- / � ��! - � ��" � # � � $ � � ".� , +#"� / � +# �  + # +

�/ :/ , #�  ! � #- / � #-� / / � ;� �# � 1/ #� #� �  � � + . � #-/ � #- � / / � �/7 � / ;

1/ #� #��  � � +� � � � ! � � "# � �$ � #- � � / � ; � � #� 1/# � #� �  � � $�2 / . � 96

1

2

#- / � +11/2 2+ #< � #- / � / $$/, # � �$ � ; -� ,- � �� � #� � ,� $�� = � +

1/  + 2#6� �$ � 8� � >� �=1 � �/ . � �  � #- / � +11/ 22+ #� 96� #-/ � � +2/ �

#+?� +"#- � � �# �/ � � � � #-/ � � #+#/ � �$ �*� - +� � �

’� 4/ � -+7/ � -/ +� . � � �� � � �@+ / �- <� 2/+�  / . � �/ � �� � ,� "  �/ 2

+ . � +926 � � "11� �# / . � 96 � � � � � @+"� +7 � � !+� ; +2 � $� � � #- /

+11/ 22+ # � + . � ��� � @�1+2 � �� ! - � ; - � � +11/ +� /. � $� � � #- /

�# +#/ � � $� *�- +� � � 4/ � -+7/ � / ?+=�  / . � #-/ � � =1" !  / . � ��. / ��

+ . � #-/ � =+#/ � � +2� � � � �/, � �. � � � � � =� +� 9+� / � � / +.�  ! � � $� #- /

�= 1" !  / . � ��. / � �< � �# � �� � , 2/+ � � #- +# � 9/$ � � / � #- / � � � ! -

�� "� #<� #- / � �  26� A"/ � #� �  � #- +#� ;+ � � +!� #+#/. � + . � +� !" / .

96 � #-/ � +11/2 2+ # � ;+ � � #-/ � A"/� #��  � �$ � :" � �� . � , #� � <

+2#- � "! - � +� $+�  #� +� ! "=/  #� ;+� � +2�� � =+./ � 96� #-/ � 2/ +� / .

,� " � /2 � $� � � #- / � +11/ 22+ #� #� � #-/ � / ?#/  #� #- +#� �= 1� �� #� �   

�$ � 8��> � 1/  +2#6 � ;+� � #� � � / ?, /� �� 7/� � */ $� � / � " � < � ���

�� @+ /� - � 2/+ �  / . � � /  � � � � , �"  � /2 � +11/+ ��  ! � $� � � #-/

+11/ 22+ # � + . � +926� +�� � � #/. � 96� � � � � @+"� +7� �! +�; +2� ;- �

/? #/  �� 7/ 26 � +� !" / . � � � #- / � A"/ � #� �  � � $ � � =1� � � #��  � � $

1/  + 2#6� + . � #- / � A" + # " =� #-/ � / � $� � � �,, � � . � ! � #� � #- / =<

#- / � A"/ � #��  � �$ � �=1 � �� #� �  � � $� 1/  +2#6<� � � #- / � $+,#� � + .

,� �, " =� #+ ,/ � � � $� #- / � 1�/ � / #� , +� /< � ,+   �# � +� � �/ � +#� +22�

��  , / � #- � � � A"/ � #� �  � ; +� �  �# � +#� +22� ! �  / � � #� � 96 � #-/

�� !- � �� "� #� / � #-/ � � � � #-/ � ;� �# � 1/ #� #��  � �� � �  � #- / � � / 7�/ ;

+112� ,+ #� �  � <� ; / � $/ /2 � �# � 1� � 1/� � #� � �/  . � #- / � ,+� / � 9+,B

2

3

#� � #- / � � � !- � �� " �# � $� � � $� /� - � . /,� � � �  � � 26 � �  � #- /

A"/� #��  � ; -/ #- /� � �= 1�� � #� � � �$ � 1/ +2#6� + . � #-/ � A" + #"=

#- /� / �$ � ; +� � 1� �1 / � � � � �  � #� � �, , �� .�  !2 6<� #- / � �=1 " !  /.

�� ./ � � � +� / � �/# � +� �. / <� 9"#� ;/ � B// 1� �# � � � �/ ,� � . � #-+#� #- /

./ ,� � ��  � �$ � #- / � � � ! - � ��" � # � � � #- / � A"/ � #� � � � $

:" �� � .� ,# � � � -+ � �  � ; � 9/, � =/ � $�  +2� + . � #-/ � �+ � . � A" /� #� �   

,+   � #�9/ � �/ � +!�# +#/ . �+$#/� � � /=+ . � �

C� �- / � � =1"!  / . � � �./ � � � +� / � +,, � � . � !2 6� � / #� +� �. / � #�

#- / � / ?#/ #� �  . �, +#/ . � +9�7/ � + . � #- / � =+##/ � � �� � �/ =� ##/ .

9+,B � #� � #- / � � � !- � � � "� # � $�� � ./ , �� � �  � � � #- / � A"/� #� �  

$� �= " 2+#/ . � +9�7/� � � -/ � �� ! - � �� " �# � � � � �/A " /� #/ . � #� � ./, � . /

#- / � �+= / � ;�# - �  � � � ? � =�  #-� � $� � = � #- / � . +#/ � � $

,� =="  � ,+ #��  � �$ � #- � � � �� . /� � #� � �#� � �- / � +11/ +2� � +� / � #-" �

+22� ; /. � �  � 1+�#� ��- / �/ � ; �22 � 9/ �  � � ��. / � � � +� � #� �,� � #� �

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � � � �� D�+� "  � �- +##/� :/ / E

�/ ; � �/2 - � F � � � � � � � � 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � �� �+ �, - � 8�< � �� �� � � � � D��� � � � �1 "� B+� E

� �� � � � �

�

3