GANGAMMA Vs DEPUTY COMMNR., CHITRADURGA .

16 January 2009
Supreme Court
Download

GANGAMMA Vs DEPUTY COMMNR., CHITRADURGA .

Bench: TARUN CHATTERJEE,H.L. DATTU, , ,
Case number: C.A. No.-000313-000313 / 2009
Diary number: 21737 / 2004

Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
1

�� � �� � ���    � �� � �  �  � �  � �� � � �� � � � � � � �   � �� �� � � ��  � �� �� ��   �

� � � � � � �     �� � � �  �� �� �   � � �� �� �� �� � �� � �  !" �  #� � �  �� $� �  � � �� %�� �  #� � �� &$

’( �� ( )) ( � �� � � * �+ +, - -( �"

� �   � � �

�. , � �,+ ! " / � � ) ) �� � �  �, �0 � �. �" � (1 !� � (0 � 2(�� ( " ( 3( � 4�  " ., � � *  , � + �1 , �" �

 �   � � � � �   �

�� �, (5 , � ��( � ", 1� �

2. �. �� � ( ++, (- � � � � 1� �, 6", 1� ( � ( �� �" � " . , � �!1 � ), � " � ( � 1� #�� ( -

� 1, � � 1(" , 1� �7 " . �  # � � ! � !� " 0� �� � &� � � � 8� �" � �+ +, ( - � � � � �99 &

# � �� � &� +(�� , 1 � :/ � ". , � � � �. � � ! �" �  # � 2( � �( " ( 3( � ("

;( �� ( - �, 0 � : / � <.� 6. � " . , � ��� . � �  ! �" � .( 1 � 1�� )� �� , 1 � ".,

(++, ( - � ) ( �� - / �  � � " . , � �� ! �1 �  # � 1,- ( / �  # � �� =� 1(/ � � ��

#� -� � � � ". , � � ( ) ,0 � (- " . ! � . �  :� , �5 (" � � � <(� � )( 1, �  � � ". ,

), �� " � � # � ". , � (++, ( - � ��

�� �( 5� � � � . , (� 1 � " ., � - , (� � ,1 � 6 !� � ,- � # � � ". , � +( � "� , � � (�1

". , � ) ( " ,� � (- � �  � � � , 6 � 1� (�1 � 6 �� � 1, �� � � � ". , � ( 5, �) , �" �

)( 1, � � � � " ., � ( ++- � 6( "�  � � # � � 6 �1  � (" �  � �  # � 1, -( /0 � <,

(� , �  # � ". , � 5�, < � " . ( " � "., � (++, - -( �" � .( � � ) ( 1, �  !"

�! ##� 6� ,� " � 6(! � , � # � � 6 � 1 � ( " �  � �  # � 1, - (/ � �� � #� - � �� � " . ,

(++, ( -� � � �" � � � � " � ! , � ". (" �  : �, � 5( "�  � � <( � � ) ( 1, � � � � " . ,

1

2

�) +! � �, 1 �  � 1,� � " . ( " � " . , � ),� � " � �  # � "., � (++, (- �  # � ". ,

(++, - -( �" � <( � � (-�  � �  " � �( " � �# (6 "  � / � :,6 ( !� , � ".,

(++, - -( �" � <( � � ( � � , 6 � 1 � +!�6 . ( � ,� � � � �� �6 , � " . , � #� �� "

+! �6 . (� ,� � .( 1 � � � � � �. " 0 � " . , �, # � ,0 � ". , � �!: � , >!, �"

+! �6 . (� ,� 0 � �() , -/ 0 � "., � ( ++,- - ( �" � 6 !- 1 � � " � � ," � (� /

�� �. " �  5, � � "., � +�  + , �" / � �� �>! , �" �  � � �� � �

&� �" � � � � "�! , � ".( " � " . , � � � � . � � !� " � . ( � � ( - �  0 � (� � � " , 1

., �, � � � ,( � -� , � 0� 1�� ) �� � , 1� "., � (++, ( - �  � � ), �� " �� � � �" � ��

<, -- � � , " " -, 1� " .(" � <. ,� � " ., � ( ++- � 6( "�  � � # � � 6 �1  � (" �  �

# � 1,-( / � �� � #� -� � � � " . , � (++, (- � <( � � "(3 , � � !+ � # � � ., ( �� �� 0

�" � < !- 1� :, � #� " � (�1 � +�  + , � � # � � " ., � �� �. � �  ! � " �  �- / � "  

� � �� "  � " ., � ), � �" � �  #� " . , � (++- �6 ( " �  � � # � � 6 �1  � ( "�  �

# � 1, - ( / � (�1 � �  " �  � � ". , � ),� � " � �  # � "., � ( ++,( - �

�. ,� , # �, 0 � " . , � �� �. � �  ! � " � <(� � �  " � ?!� " � #�, 1 � � �

1� �) � �� �� � � " ., � (++, (- �  � � ) , � � "� � <. , � � ". , � ( ++-� 6( " �  �

# � � 6 � 1 �( " �  � �  # � 1,- (/ � <( � �  �- / � + � " , 1 � # � � ., (� � ��

:, # � , ��" � � �� �

=� 8, � (66 �1 �� � -/ � �, " � (�� 1, � " . , � �)+ ! � �, 1�  �1, � � ( � 1� ( -- <

". , � (++, ( - � ( � 1� � , ) � " � "., � 6( �, � :( 63� " � " ., � � � �. � � ! �"

# � � 1, 6�� � � � � � � (66 �1 ( � 6, � <� " . � - ( < � (#" , � � �� 5�� �

., (� � �� � " � "., � +( � " �, � � ( �1 � ( #", � � +(�� � � � � ( � � ,(�  � , 1

� 1, � � ��

2

3

9� �. , � ��� . � �  ! �" � �� � � ,>! , � ", 1� " � 1,6 � 1, � " ., � (++,( - � <�" . � �

". �, , � )  � ". � � #� ) � ". , � 1( " , �  # � �! ++- / �  # � ( � 6 +/ �  # � ". ��

� 1, � � �� � .,� , � <�- - � :, �� �  � 1, � � (� � " �6 � "� �

* * * * * * * * * � � @� �   � � � � � � � � �   � � � A

� � 8� � � �� � B � � � � � � � � � � � * * * * * * * * * � � � � � � � �   C� � 90� � � � � � � � � � � � @� � � � � � � � � � � A

3