http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 2  

CASE NO.: Appeal (civil)  267 of 2007

PETITIONER: PRANAY MAJUMDAR                              ...APPELLANT(S)

RESPONDENT: BINA MAJUMDAR                                       ...RESPONDENT(S)

DATE OF JUDGMENT: 17/01/2007

BENCH: Dr.AR.LAKSHMANAN & V.S. SIRPURKAR

JUDGMENT: J U D G M E N T

(Arising out of SLP(C) No.7430/2004)  

Dr.AR.LAKSHMANAN, J.  

       Delay condoned.

       Leave granted.         This appeal is directed against the final judgment/order  dt.02.12.2003 passed in FMA No.1401 of 2000 by the High Court of  Calcutta.           The appellant before us is the husband of the respondent herein.   The appellant filed an application under Section 27(d) of the Special  Marriage Act, 1954 in the City Civil Court at Calcutta being Matrimonial  Suit No.268 of 1991 seeking divorce from the respondent alleging cruelty.   Later, the suit was transferred to the Family Court, Calcutta and re- numbered as Matrimonial Suit No.103/1995.  The suit filed by the  appellant was decreed by the trial court.  Aggrieved against the order of  the trial court, the respondent filed F.M.A.No.1401 of 2000 in the High  Court and the High Court by the impugned order, allowed the  F.M.A.No.1401 of 2000.  Hence, the present appeal has been filed in this  Court.  During the pendency of the appeal, we passed the following Order  on 26.09.2006 :-         "After hearing both parties, we pass the following Order on  25.08.2006 :-            "The Husband is the petitioner before us, who had  filed the petition for divorce before the Family Court, which  was allowed.  Aggrieved against the said order, the  respondent-wife filed an appeal before the High Court, which  was allowed.  Aggrieved against the order of the High Court,  Husband has come up before us by way of filing the instant  special leave petition.           It is now stated that though the marriage took place  on 25.9.1987, the parties are not living together from  29.6.1990 onwards and there is no hope for the parties living  together peacefully.  The learned counsel for the respondent- wife has also submitted that living together hereafter by both  parties is not possible, and therefore, if suitable  compensation by way of permanent alimony  is granted, an  order can be passed dissolving the marriage.  The learned  counsel for the petitioner-husband offers a sum of  Rs.3,00,000/- by way of permanent alimony to the  respondent-wife in full and final settlement of the entire  claim.  The learned counsel for the husband further submits  that the husband owns certain land and he can sell the land  and pay money to the respondent-wife.  For that, he needs  some time.  Since a proposal has been made today, we direct  the learned counsel for the respondent-wife to ascertain the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 2  

views of the respondent and then report to us.  We direct  both the parties to be present in person in this Court on 26th  September, 2006.  Post this matter on 26th September, 2006  (NMD)."

       When the matter came up today for hearing, both the  parties filed a Joint Memorandum of Settlement duly signed by all  the parties and attested by the counsel appearing on either side.   The same is taken on record.    The Joint Memorandum of  Settlement reads thus :-         "(1)That the petitioner-husband shall pay a sum of  Rs.3,00,000/- (Three lacs only) in full and final settlement of  all the claims of the wife towards permanent alimony within a  period of 3 months or earlier by demand draft.   2       That the respondent wife shall have no claim of any kind  including any claim over the plot of land measuring 2 Kottah  1 Chhittak 15 sq.ft., Naihati No.168 in Dag No.68 under  Municipal Corporation of Halishahar, Mauza: Balibhara, 24  Parganas (North), West Bengal under sub-Registry of Naihati,  registered on 26.2.1988 (WB).  The petitioner husband shall  be exclusive owner in possession of the said land. 3        That all original paper/document pertaining to the aforesaid  plot of land which are in custody of the respondent wife shall  be returned to the petitioner, within a period of 10 days from  today. 4       That the respondent - wife shall not create any obstruction in  disposing of the said plot of land by the petitioner if he so  desires. 5       That the said amount of Rs.3 lacs by demand draft as  permanent alimony shall be paid by the petitioner - husband  to the respondent wife within a period of 3 months or earlier.   On receipt of the said amount, the Criminal Revision  Application pending before the Calcutta High Court, preferred  by the respondent-wife against the order dt.31.12.2004  passed in M.Case No.38/2000 (T.R.No.64/2000) by the IVth  Judicial Magistrate, Barracpore, West Bengal under Section  125 Cr.P.C. shall stand withdrawn. 6       That on payment of the said amount of Rs.3 lacs; the  respondent wife shall not claim any future maintenance for  her and/or for her daughter born out of the wedlock with her  first husband. 7       That while granting the leave, the instant appeal may be  allowed and accordingly the decree of divorce may be  granted on the above said terms."

         Place this matter on 09.01.2007 for reporting  compliance."         It is now represented by the learned counsel for the appellant  that pursuant to the joint Memorandum of Settlement, a sum of  Rs.3,00,000/- (three lacs) in full and final settlement of all the claims of  the respondent-wife as a permanent alimony was paid to him by way of  a demand draft.  The learned counsel for the respondent-wife has also  stated that he has received the demand draft for a sum of Rs.3,00,000/-  (three lacs).  The respondent, as per Memorandum of Settlement, shall  not claim any future claim for her and her daughter who is residing with  her first husband.  In view of the settlement now reached between the  parties, the order of the High Court impugned in this appeal is set aside  and there will be a decree of divorce as ordered by the trial court in  respect of the appellant and the respondent.  The appeal stands  disposed of accordingly.  No costs.