D.D. VAISHNAV Vs STATE OF M.P. .
Bench: TARUN CHATTERJEE,H.L. DATTU, , ,
Case number: C.A. No.-000449-000449 / 2009
Diary number: 34009 / 2007
Advocates: KAILASH CHAND Vs
B. S. BANTHIA
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �
� � � �� � � �� � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � �� � � �� � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � �
� �� � � �� � � � � � � � � � �� � �� � � � �� � � � � � � ! " � # � � $� %� � � &� &’ � # � � � �( %
�� �� � �) �� * �) + � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � , �- -. / /) �"
� � � �
" )" . � # � �� ��� � )� 0� �"* . � � � , �. � - �0 . �" �
� � � � � � � � �
&� . )+ . � ��) � ". 0�
2. �* �� � �� � )� � ) - - .) / � #� 1 � ) � � �0 . � � 0) " .0 � &� "� #
�! �! � "2 � � ��’ � -) � � .0 � 34� " *. � �� � * � � ! �" � #
�� �� � ) " � � )3) / - !� � �� � 5� � " � �- -. )/ � � � � &&�� � #
�� �’ � #� /. 0 � !�0 . � � . 6"� � � �7 &8� # � " *. � �� � �
�6 6*) � � 4) 4) / ) 4) � 79*) �0 � � 4)4) � �.. " * � :
�- -. ) /8 � � 0*� � � 4)12 � � � � ;2 � 34 � <*�6 * � " * .
�� +� � � � � .� 6* � # � "* . � �� � * � � !� " � * )0
�. =. 6". 0� "*. � ) --/ � 6) "� � � # � � 6 � 0 � )" � � � #
0. /) 4 � # � ;(� � 0)4� � �� � #�/ � �� � " *. � )- -. ) /
)� )� � �" � )� � �0 . � � 0) ". 0� � � "* � #� �6" 3. �2 � � ��;
1
# � "* . � /. ) �� .0 � � � � /. � � ! 0� . � # � "*. � �� �*
� !� " � �� � 5�� � � 7�8 � ’ (>; � #� ��� � � ��
?� 5. � * )+. � * .)� 0 � "*. � / .)� � . 0 � 6 ! � �. / � # � � " *.
-) �" � .� � ) �0 � .@) 1� � . 0� "*. � �1 -! � �. 0� �0 . � � )�
<. // � )� � " *. � )- - /� 6) " � � � # � � 6 �0 � ) "� � � #
0. /) 4� �� � #� / �� � � " * . � )- -. )/ � � � �)+ � � � � .@)1�� .0
"* . � ) +. �1 . �" � � 1) 0. � � � � " * . � ) -- /� 6) " � � � # �
6 �0 �) "� � � # � 0. / ) 4 � � � � #�/ � � � � " *. � )- -. ) /
)� 0 � ) #" .� � * . ) � �� � � "* . � / . )� � . 0 � 6 !� � ./ � # �
"* . � - ) � "� .� 2 � <. � )�. � � ) " � �# � .0 � "* )" � "* .
)- -/ � 6) "� � � # � � 6 � 0 � ) " � � � #� 0./ ) 4� # � ;( �
0)4� � � � � - �.# . � �� � � � "*. � )- - . )/ � 1! �" � 3.
)/ / <.0 � ) � � "*. � �" )" . 1. �" � � �� � "*. � ) --/ � 6) "� �
# � � 6 � 0 � )" � � � # � 0./ ) 42 � �� � !� � +�.< 2 � 0
6 �� " �" !" . � �!# #�6 �. �" � 6) !� . � � � � � "
-� .# . �� �� � � "*. � )- -. ) / � <� " *� � � "*. � - .�� 0� #
/� 1� " )" � � � � � �6 6 �0 �� � /4 2 � "*. � )- -/ �6 ) " � �
# � � 6 � 0 � )" � � � # � 0./ ) 4� �� � - �.# . � � �� � � "*.
)- -. ) / � � � � ) / / <. 0� ) �0 � " * . � �1- ! �� .0 � � 0. � � � �
�. " � )�� 0. � � �� � � � �� �
�� �* . � ) - - .) / � ��2 � " * . � .# � . 2 � ) / / < . 0 � " � "* .
.@". � " � �� 0�6 )" .0 � ) 3 + . � � � � * . � ��� * � � ! � " � � �
�. A!. �" .0 � " � 0� � - � . � #� "*. � ) --. ) / � � � 1. � � "�
2
�� � ) 66 � 0) �6 . � <�" * � /)< � ) #". � � ��+ � � � � *.) � �� �
" � " *. � -) � "� .� � )� 0� )#" . � � - ) � � �� � � ) � �. )� � . 0
� 0. � � � ! 3=. 6" � " � - ) 41. �" � # � 6 �" � #
�� �& � 2� �� BC2 � " � 3. � 0.- � �" . 0B-) � 0 � " � "* .
�. �- �0 .� " � <�" * �� � �� @� <. .: � � #� 1 � " *. � 0) " . � #
�! -- / 4� # � ) � 6 - 4� # � "* �� � � 0. � � " � "*. � � ��*
� !� " 2 � � � � 0. #) ! /" � # � -)4 1.� " � # � "* .
)# � . �) �0 � )1 ! � "2 � "* � � � )- -. )/ � �* )/ /2
* <. +.� 2 � � ") �0 � 0� �1 � �� .0 � ) � 0 � "*. � �1 -! �� .0
� 0. � � # � "*. � �� �* � � !� " � � *) // � �" )� 0
)##� � 1. 0� � � �*. � � � � * � � !� " � � � � #!� " * . �
�. A!. �" .0 � " � 0� � - � . � # � "*. � 1)"" . � � <� "* � �
"* �. . � 1 � " *� � #� 1� "* . � 0) ". � # � 0. - � �" � # � "*.
6 �" � )� � ) <)� 0. 0� ��
, , , , , , , , , , , � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � %
� � 5� � � � � D� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ,, , , , , , , , , , � � � � � � � � E� �’ 2� � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � %
3